The Cornelius Vanderbilt II Mansion on 57th Street and 5th Avenue, now demolished. Photo via A.D. White Architectural Photographs, Cornell University Library.
New York City’s Fifth Avenue has always been pretty special, althoughyou’d probably never guess that it began with a rather ordinary and functional name: Middle Road. Like the 1811 Commissioner’sPlan for Manhattan,whichlaid out the city’s future expansion in a rational manner, Middle Road was part of an earlier real estate plan by the City Council. As its name suggests, Middle Road was situated in the middle of a large land parcel that was sold by the council in 1785 to raise municipal funds for the newly established nation. Initially, it was the only road to provide access to this yet-undeveloped portionof Manhattan, but two additional roads were built later (eventually becomingPark Avenue and Sixth Avenue). The steady northwards march of upscale residences, and the retail to match, has its origins where Fifth Avenue literally begins: in the mansions onWashington Square Park. Madison Square was next, butit would take acombination of real-estate clairvoyance and social standing to firmly establish Fifth Avenue as the center of society.
Mrs. Astor’shome viaWikimedia
The catalyst for Fifth Avenue’s transformation came in the form of the Astor family. Patriarch John Jacob Astor had purchased large swaths of Manhattanin the aforementioned land sales, allowing William Backhouse Astor Sr. to present his son and the new Caroline Astor (née Webster Schermerhorn) with a parcel of land on 34th Street and 5th Avenue as a wedding gift in 1854.
Old money didn’t need to flaunt, however, so the resulting home was a rather modest brownstone. But the arrival of upstarts A.T. Stewart across the street forced Caroline into action. Following extensive interior renovations in the French Rococo style, the first “Mrs. Astor’s House” was born. It was also here that societal standing was attained and lost, amidst the famous 400 (named so because it was simply how many people could fit into Mrs. Astor’s ballroom). The ballroom, sumptuously appointed with floor-to-ceiling artwork and a massive chandelier,was built in a new wing that replaced the stables.
With new fortunes being made overnight in the new center of world commerce that was New York, it was only logical that the new millionaires each needed their own mansions along 5thAvenue.
Here is a guide to the Gilded Age mansions on 5th Avenue, both those still standing and those lost.
The Vanderbilt Triple Palace:640 and 660 Fifth Avenue and 2 West 52nd Street: Demolished
Image from Public Domain from theA. D. White Architectural Photographs Collection, Cornell University Library
These three townhouses, built in 1882 and known as the “Triple Palaces,” were given to the daughters of William Henry Vanderbilt, son of Commodore Cornelius Vanderbilt. These buildings occupied the entire block between 51st and 52nd Street on 5th Avenue, along with the corner of 52nd Street. Henry Clay Frick was so taken in bythe construction of 640 5th Avenue that he is quoted to have said,“That is all I shall ever want” on a drive past the Triple Palaceswith his friend Andrew Mellon.
Indeed, Frick set out to emulate the art collection of Vanderbilt and even moved into 640 5th Avenue in 1905 with a 10-year lease, while George Vanderbilt was preoccupied with building the Biltmore Estate in North Carolina. He would have bought the house if William H. Vanderbilt’s will had not barred Georgefrom selling the home and art outsideof the family. Later, via a loophole, the property and artwork was able to be sold by Vanderbilt’sgrandson to the Astors, who in turn sold the holdings in the 1940s.
The buildings, considered anachronistic, were demolished and replaced byskyscrapers. Today, they are home to retailersH&M, Godiva, and Juicy Couture, while Frick’s art collection and mansion remain intact (including the secret bowling alley underground) on 70th Street and 5th Avenue.
+++
Morton F. Plant House and George W. Vanderbilt House, 4 E. 52nd Street, 645 and 647 Fifth Avenue
Via Wikimedia
In 1905, Architect C.P.H Gilbert built thisAmerican Renaissance mansion at the corner of 52nd Street and 5th Avenuefor Morgan Freeman Plant, son of the railroad tycoon Henry B. Plant. Today, it’s been converted into the Cartier store but the original front entrance of the home was on 52nd Street.Next door were mansions of George W. Vanderbilt, son of William Henry Vanderbilt. The homes, designed by Hunt & Hunt also in 1905, were known as the “Marble Twins.” The AIA Guide to New York Citydescribes both the Plant and Vanderbilt homes as “free interpretation[s] of sixteenth- and seventeenth-century palazzi.”The Vanderbilt mansionat 645 was demolished but 647 remains,now the Versace store.
+++
William K. Vanderbilt Mansion at 660 Fifth Avenue: Demolished
The William K. Vanderbilt Mansion. Image source: Library of Congress
Diagonally across from the Morton F. Plant House was the William K. Vanderbilt Mansion, whichWilliam’swife, Alva Vanderbilt, commissioned from RichardMorris Hunt in a French-Renaissance and Gothic style in 1878. The mansion, affectionately referred to as the Petit Chateau, was part of Alva Vanderbilt’s tenacious attempt to break into the 400 society, in a time when new money was still looked down upon.
According to the bookFortune’s Childrenby Vanderbilt descendant Arthur T. Vanderbilt II, architect “Hunt knew his new young clients very well, and he understood the function of architecture as a reflection of ambition. He sensed that Alva wasn’t interested in another home. She wanted a weapon: a house she could use as a battering ram to crash through the gates of society.” The interiors were decorated from trips to Europe, with items from both antique shops and from “pillaging the ancient homes of impoverished nobility.”The facade was of Indiana limestone and the grand hall built of stone quarried from Caen, France.
But a grand house enough wasn’t enough, and she battled back with a ball of her own in which she invited more than the usual 400. 1,200 of New York’s finest were invited to this fancy dress ball in 1883, but not Mrs. Astor, who promptly, and finally, called on Alva’s new “upstart” home to guarantee an invitation to the ball for her and her daughter.
The ball was as incredible as promised with the New York Press head over heels. The New York Times called is “Mrs. W.K. Vanderbilt’s Great Fancy Dress Ball” where“Mrs. Vanderbilt’s irreproachable taste was seen to perfection in her costume.” The New York World went as far to say that it was an “event never equalled in the social annals of the metropolis.” At a $250,000 cost, this social coup solidified the Vanderbilt family in New York society.
Sadly, themansion was demolished in 1926 after being sold to a real estate developer and in its stead rose 666 Fifth Avenue. Today, you’ll find a Zara occupying the retail floor.
+++
680 and 684 Fifth Avenue Townhouses: Demolished
Photo of the Webb and Twombly mansions via Wikimedia
These two townhouses by architect John B. Snook were builtin 1883 forFlorence Adele Vanderbilt TwomblyandEliza Osgood Vanderbilt Webb as gifts from William H. Vanderbilt. Florence lived in 684until 1926 when she upgraded to a new mansion further north along Central Park. The Webbs sold 680 to John D. Rockefeller in 1913. Both were demolished for a skyscraper that has The Gap as its anchor tenant.
+++
The Cornelius Vanderbilt II Mansion 742-748 Fifth Avenue: Demolished
Image via Library of Congress
Cornelius Vanderbilt II used the inheritance from his father the Commodore to purchase three brownstones on the corner of 57th Street and 5th Avenue, demolish them and build this mansion. According to the bookFortune’s Childrenby Vanderbiltdescendant Arthur T. Vanderbilt II,it was “common belief that Alice Vanderbilt set out to dwarfher sister in law [Alva Vanderbilt]‘s Fifth Avenue chateau, and dwarf it she did.”Cornelius’ mansion was allegedlythe largest single-family house in New York City at the time, and its brick and limestone facade further differentiated it from its neighbors.
It gradually became eclipsed by even larger commercial skyscrapers and was sold to a realty corporation in 1926, whodemolished the home and built the Bergdorf Goodman department store in its place. Still, a fun expedition is to track down the remnants of this mansion which are now scattered around Manhattan,including the front gates that are now in Central Park, sculptural reliefs now in the Sherry-Netherland Hotel, and a grand fireplace now in the Metropolitan Museum of Art.
In Fifth Avenue’s evolution from mansions to luxury retail, two factors sustained its elegance, according to theAIA Guide to New York City:
“The Fifth Avenue Association (whose members had fought billboards, bootblacks, parking lots, projecting signs–even funeral parlors), and the absence of els or subways. To provide a genteel alternative for rapid transit, the Fifth Avenue Transportation Company was established in 1885, using horse-drawn omnibuses until 1907, followed by the fondly remembered double-deck buses. Once upon a time even the traffic lights were special: bronze standards with neo-Grec Mercury atop, subsidized by the Fifth Avenue Association concerned with style.”
+++
Editor’s note: The original version of this article was published on August 22, 2017, and has since been updated.
RELATED:A Guide to the Gilded Age Mansions of 5th Avenue’s Millionaire Row – Part II
Michelle Young is the founder ofUntapped Cities, a publication and tour company about urban exploration and discovery in New York City. She is also an adjunct professor at Columbia University Graduate School of Architecture, Planning and Preservation. Followher on Twitter@untappedmich.
